Cultural Confidence: Why Everyone Should Stop Copying Other Companies' Workplace Culture

Written By Nikki Strickland

It's no secret, social media and the internet is flattening modern culture. Smash burgers, matcha, New Balance, the list of "basics" is getting long. Last week we were in Manhattan, excited to get Pop-up bagels, only to return to find out we will have one in our neighborhood soon. They suddenly became less desirable.

Social media algos are creating a gravitational pull toward sameness.

The Workplace Culture Copy-Paste Problem

The same thing has been happening to workplace culture strategy for years. Remember the mid-2000s rush to "be like Google"? I was a head of HR and Culture at the time, completely enamored with these examples. Suddenly, every office needed open floor plans, bean bags, and kombucha on tap. The Netflix Culture Deck was passed around boardrooms more than the LTI calculator.

The irony was that our organization actually had an amazing employee engagement culture. I can say that now, with hindsight and a decade of experience evaluating other cultures. It was certainly "different" and unorthodox, but it got results. But at the time, it was easy to think that you needed to replicate others because they were successful. Now we know that in many cases, culture isn't what made them successful.

Performance vs. Practice: What CHROs Miss About Culture Transformation

They were being copied due to the performance of culture, not the practice of it. Those tech companies weren't great places to work because they had kombucha machines. The kombucha was just what you could see. What you couldn't see were the decision-making frameworks, the actual behaviors that got rewarded, the real conversations happening when problems arose.

Netflix's culture transformation wasn't radical because of how it was written. It was radical because they actually fired high performers who didn't fit their values. Most companies loved the language about "dream teams" but weren't willing to have the difficult conversations or make the hard decisions that created that culture.

Cultural Confidence: The Secret to Authentic Workplace Culture

Organizations with genuinely great cultures have something in common: they're not trying to be anyone else. They have what we call "cultural confidence," the belief that their way of working actually matters.

Take our client PulteGroup, a Fortune 100 Great Places to Work company with top 5% Gallup employee engagement scores globally. They didn't get there by copying Silicon Valley playbooks. They built their workplace culture around what matters in their business: hiring smart people and training them to build incredible places where people live their dreams. Sounds simple, but trust us, it's a hard (hard) and consistent commitment to excellence.

Why Authentic Culture Beats AI and Algorithms

As AI makes many tasks feel increasingly standardized, authentic workplace culture becomes one of the few sustainable advantages organizations have. But building it requires patience with being different and the discipline to focus on what actually works rather than what gets the most likes.

The companies that will thrive aren't the ones with the most innovative office design. They're the ones brave enough to figure out who they actually are and confident enough to be that, consistently, even when no one's watching.

The Future of Culture Strategy for HR Leaders

Because real culture transformation, like real people, can't be copy-pasted. It can't be "flattened."

And maybe that's exactly the point.

For CHROs and HR leaders, the challenge isn't finding the next culture trend to copy—it's developing the cultural confidence to build something authentic to your organization. In a world of increasing sameness, authentic workplace culture becomes your competitive advantage.

Culture Edit Podcast:

Ep. 103 - Kristen Mayer, Betty Designs

In this episode with Kristin Mayer, mom, designer and athlete, we explore her journey that led her to create the iconic brand Betty Designs. From her early days in art school to her time at legendary brand LA Gear, she shares her story of entrepreneurship and how she and Betty Designs have evolved together over the years. We discuss industry trends, sources of design inspiration, and how sometimes you just have to let copycats roll off your back (even though it's tough). If you're looking for inspiration for that new idea or want to learn more about how cycling brands are built, this episode is for you. Proof that grit, passion, and hard work always pay off.

Nikki Strickland
Next

Performance-Based Culture Strategy: How CHROs Navigate Market-Driven Employee Value Systems